Cheap Car Hire in Finger Lakes from just $92

Looking for cheap car hire deals in Finger Lakes? Search right here on momondo!

Driver's age: 26-65

Discover deals from car hire companies in 70,000+ locations with momondo.

Best deals found for Finger Lakes car hire

Find great deals below on a variety of popular hire cars in Finger Lakes

Hyundai Elantra

or similar Intermediate

Up to 5 passengers

$92/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Toyota Yaris

or similar Economy

Up to 2 passengers

$95/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Toyota Camry

or similar Standard

Up to 5 passengers

$97/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Mitsubishi Mirage

or similar Economy

Up to 2 passengers

5-door vehicles

$102/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Holden Barina

or similar Economy

Up to 2 passengers

$103/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Toyota Corolla

or similar Compact

Up to 4 passengers

$103/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Toyota Camry

or similar Full-size

Up to 5 passengers

$104/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Hyundai Avante

or similar Intermediate

Up to 5 passengers

$105/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Nissan Frontier

or similar Pick-up truck

Up to 5 passengers

$105/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Car hire insight and trends in Finger Lakes

Useful insights to help you book the perfect car hire in Finger Lakes

Companies

Other Information

What is the best car hire agency in Finger Lakes?

If you plan on visiting Finger Lakes, consider hiring a car from Hertz, which is the best car hire company in the region with 7 locations. 110 momondo reviewers gave this rental agency an average rating of 5.6 out of 10 for their reasonable prices and customer service. You can find Hertz in Ithaca and many other cities throughout Finger Lakes.

Finger Lakes car hire deals found on momondo

Find the car hire in Finger Lakes that's right for you

	Small cars	$63 - $294
	All Car Types	$63 - $208

The average price of a small car hire in Finger Lakes is $67. The cheapest time to hire a small car in Finger Lakes is in August. The price is 8% lower than the rest of the year at just $63 per day. A small car rental is typically 18% less expensive than the average rental car in Finger Lakes. The average price of a vehicle hire in Finger Lakes can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your car hire. Below are the best prices for Finger Lakes small car hire found on momondo in the past week.

The average price of a medium car hire in Finger Lakes is $53. The cheapest time to hire a medium car in Finger Lakes is in July. The price is 7% lower than the rest of the year at just $58 per day. A medium car rental is typically 35% less expensive than the average rental car in Finger Lakes. The average price of a vehicle hire in Finger Lakes can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your car hire. Below are the best prices for Finger Lakes medium car hire found on momondo in the past week.

The average price of a SUV hire in Finger Lakes is $68. The cheapest time to hire a SUV in Finger Lakes is in June. The price is 0% lower than the rest of the year at just $68 per day. A SUV rental is typically 18% less expensive than the average rental car in Finger Lakes. The average price of a vehicle hire in Finger Lakes can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your car hire. Below are the best prices for Finger Lakes SUV hire found on momondo in the past week.

Toyota Yaris

or similar Economy

Up to 2 passengers

$95/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Holden Barina

or similar Economy

Up to 2 passengers

$102/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Kia Picanto

or similar Economy

Up to 2 passengers

$103/day

30 May - 1 Jun

See offer

Finger Lakes car hire directory

All major car hire suppliers in Finger Lakes

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

8.3

Very Good

34 reviews•9 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|June 2023

No issues!

10.0

Wonderful|May 2023

Everything was great. The car, the service.

8.0

Very Good|Feb 2023

I asked for an email receipt so I didn't notice they had my drop-off location wrong - a bodyshop in Buffalo instead of the Syracuse airport. Luckily, I spotted the error in time and Enterprise fixed it right away over the phone.

10.0

Wonderful|Feb 2023

Everything about this rental experience was great. Easy pickup, clean car, easy drop off, and friendly employees at every step.

10.0

Wonderful|Oct 2022

Very good staff at desk (Kevin)

8.0

Very Good|Aug 2022

Overall very good. I still don’t understand why it takes so long at pick up!

1 out of 12

Avis

7.5

Good

33 reviews•5 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

4.0

Mediocre|May 2024

We got a different car which has lower value for rent. Neither got the price adjustment nor time adjustment.

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

Heavy Cigarette smell in car Charged us double the price on our credit card even though receipt is for correct amount. Still disputing this matter Very difficult to contact local Avis.. rolls over to national call center.. very frustrating

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

The vehicle provided was fine, but not the one/size reserved. Rented an 11-passenger van months ahead (to transport a wedding party). Got the rental, and it was a 7-passenger Yukon Denali. The person at the counter said, "we never get 11 passenger vans here." The rental person was totally unhelpful. She said they usually call people in advance to warn them, but for some reason, they didn’t call us. She said they'd be glad to rent us a second Yukon (at full cost to US!). After we expressed our dissatisfaction, she said she could check Elmira or Syracuse and we could drive there to exchange it. After calling, no passenger vans were available. They charged us over $1900.00 for a week long rental that we couldn't even use for the wedding. We ended up getting an ACTUAL 11 person van from Enterprise and our Avis rental sat in the driveway all week. I will never recommend Avis to anyone!

2.0

Poor|June 2023

I had a terrible experience with Avis. In the past, I’ve had positive experiences, but I can’t say the same this time. When I went to pick up my vehicle, which was a 12 passenger van, I was told that there was no phone number on file to confirm so they did not schedule a van to arrive. I pulled up my confirmation info and could see my email and a valid phone number. The associate insisted that there was none on file. I was very confused since I had even received an email the day before telling me to “enjoy my ride!” There were no other passenger vans available so they were unable to accommodate us that day. This was a trip that had been planned for a long time and I was upset that Avis could not come through. I am very disappointed and will not book through Avis again.

10.0

Wonderful|Mar 2023

Very friendly personnel, super quick service.

4.0

Mediocre|Mar 2023

Vehicle needed maintenance, vibrated badly probly needed a front end alignment or tire balance. Only had to use it an hour a day otherwise would've taken it back.

1 out of 11

Budget

7.3

Good

44 reviews•5 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|Aug 2023

Nothing

6.0

Okay|June 2023

Good vehicle, clean, easy pick-up and drop-off. Wish I had known how to disable the toll receiver, because budget charges a lot of money for that. However, charges on the credit card are fishy. I pre-paid rent and insurance, but got a vague "non-pkg items" charge of 80$. After complaining, I got explanation that that is for fuel, while I had asked for full-to-full policy. They then refunded the charge, but on the same day made the same charge again, now from another budget office. Still don't have my money back, get all kinds of mails for more details on the credit card transactions, but no fix.

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2023

I really like that one of the Budget employees at the desk assisted me to find another vehicle when the car I was originally assigned had a problem.

2.0

Poor|Feb 2023

Seemingly everything that could’ve gone wrong happened too. I was given a completely different car that was awful on gas, told the car was full with gas but it was at 3/4 tank (of a 24 gallon tank). The car wreaked of air freshener, no washer fluid so couldn’t see through the windshield the whole drive. Got blackmailed about a cleaning fee when dropping off. The person checked out the car in the first place was the only positive experience. Will not be renting from Budget again.

8.0

Very Good|Feb 2023

The car smelled like weed whenever it was humid or had been sitting overnight. The carpet was sticking out and had clearly been pulled up on the passenger side and there were stains on the seat. Other than that the car was fine and the staff were very friendly

10.0

Wonderful|Feb 2023

However I reserved a truck and the did not have a truck available.

1 out of 15

Dollar

6.4

Okay

45 reviews•4 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

Long lines for pickup due to single Hertz counter that was also serving Dollar customers with onky one agent at counter. Car not cleaned and filthy. No checking process; I still have not received a final bill. Never again using Dollar/Hertz.

4.0

Mediocre|July 2023

The pickup process for Dollar is broken. They make reservations without having the cars to fill them. Every other company had no line, while Dollar had 15 people in line because they had no cars to rent. We waited an hour for a car to “be cleaned” and given to us. The employee was unapologetic and dressed in athletic shorts and a gray T-shirt while giving the impression that he didn’t care. Meanwhile, I returned the car 18 hours ago and I still haven’t seen a turn in receipt in my email. Pay the extra money and rent from someone else.

8.0

Very Good|Mar 2023

customer service was great The truck had not been cleaned prior to my renting it.

8.0

Very Good|Nov 2022

CSR’s were lacking in courtesy.

2.0

Poor|Oct 2022

I reserved weeks ahead of time, but when I got there, thu said that they didn't have a car. They explained that they book many more reservations than they actually have cars for. They didn't seem to care about that policy negatively affecting travelers. I waited for two hours, and was eventually able to get a car. Th clerk wasn't apologetic in the slightest.

10.0

Wonderful|Sept 2022

Did get car which was booked got alternative but was as good very spacious

1 out of 15

Hertz

5.6

Fair

79 reviews•7 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

Desk agent attempted to up-sell every markup possible. Did not even present the options of not purchasing insurance, attempted to add a driver (my wife) without my consent, pushed excessive toll package despite knowing route had minimal tolls, and even said “what if something bad happens to you” when I continuously declined these frivolous packages.

8.0

Very Good|July 2023

The wait to get a car was a bit long. The rest was good.

2.0

Poor|July 2023

-0 I was not told and given a car that required battery re charge! Takes hours to refill and places to refill are scarce!! I would never knowingly rent a car like this

2.0

Poor|July 2023

Even though I had a confirmation there was no car. Wasted 40 dollars on an Uber to get to the location from the airport. Will never use hertz again.

2.0

Poor|June 2023

Waited for 45 minutes in a long line to rent my car. Missed an important meeting.

8.0

Very Good|June 2023

No hybrid

1 out of 27

National

2 locations

Check prices

Overview

Alamo

8.5

Very Good

2 reviews•2 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|June 2022

I showed up to find out there were no cars available even with the reservation. After leaving the airport I was able to make another reservation about 2 hours later. There is no way to call the Representatives at the airport to find out if there were in fact cars there. So I called what must have been an Alamo corporate office and was assured there were in fact cars available. I then went back to the airport to pick up a car to find out there are still no cars available. Alamo enterprise, hertz, the entire fleet at the Syracuse airport was allowing reservations but had no cars to rent. This was an absolutely miserable experience.

1 out of 1

Payless

7.2

Good

7 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|July 2023

The SUV was quite comfortable but was filthy when we picked it up. Originally I thought I requested a small SUV but when I got to the counter I was told otherwise. He offered an upgrade for the infinity SUV so I agreed. After paying and picking up the vehicle it was noted to be filthy and smelled strongly of cigarette smoke. To the point it made us nauseated. I am on chemotherapy and we also had a 5 year old with us. Me being on chemo made the smoke sensitivity worse. We were in a tight deadline after we picked it up to get to our destination so I couldn’t exchange it. I mentioned it to the clerk in the parking garage but was told us have to go back inside the airport. As above, we didn’t have time to spare. Upon return I mentioned to the attendant in the airport, she took my name and number then assured me a manager would call. It’s been 3 days later now and no phone call. Very disappointed in this transaction and likely to never rent from Payless again. Would ultimately appreciate some sort of compensation for the filthy vehicle.

6.0

Okay|Apr 2022

a different rate was offered online and on the phone from in person for extending the trip this means that I had to drive to the airport to book an extra day for my rental

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2022

Pick up and drop off were simple.

1 out of 3

Car hire in Finger Lakes

Learn everything there is to know about hiring a car in Finger Lakes so you can be properly prepared for your next trip

When did momondo last update prices for cars in Finger Lakes?

Prices for cars in Finger Lakes refresh daily.

How many operators does momondo search for cars in Finger Lakes?

The number of operators available for cars in Finger Lakes is 10 as of April 2025.

How old do you have to be to hire a car in Finger Lakes?

Age requirements for drivers vary depending on the country, including Finger Lakes. In several EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. Generally, to hire a car overseas, you must be at least 21 years old, and if you're under 25, you may be charged a young driver surcharge. It's recommended that you review the policy of your preferred hire company before booking.

What documentation or ID do you need to hire a car in Finger Lakes?

All drivers must have a valid full driving license when hiring a car in Finger Lakes. If the license is written in a different language from the country of hire, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're hiring a car overseas, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. It is always advisable to check with the individual hire company you're booking with.

Why use momondo?

Why should I use momondo to book a car hire in Finger Lakes?

You should use momondo to book a car hire in Finger Lakes because it could save you time and money. momondo fetches and allows you to compare car hire prices and policies from thousands of car hire websites.

How does momondo help me find the best car hire deal in Finger Lakes?

momondo enables you to find the best car hire deal in Finger Lakes by providing useful filters to narrow your search. Filters include, but are not limited to: price, body type, rental company and specific policies that you may want.